Debunking Antisemitic Fabrications about the Talmud
Misinformation and distortions of Jewish religious texts like the Talmud are a cornerstone of antisemitic propaganda. The claims presented in the image you shared are a clear example of fabricated or decontextualized quotes designed to incite hatred against Jews. Below, we address and refute these lies systematically.
1. “Murdering Goyim is like killing a wild animal.” (Sanhedrin 59a)
Truth: This quote is entirely fabricated. Sanhedrin 59a discusses the Noahide laws, universal moral laws that apply to all humanity. Far from endorsing violence, the text emphasizes ethical behavior and justice for all people, not just Jews. The Talmud strongly opposes murder in any form.
2. “Even the best of the Gentiles should be killed.” (Abodah Zarah 26b)
Truth: This is a blatant misrepresentation. The context of this discussion in the Talmud relates to wartime scenarios during the ancient world when survival against hostile armies was a matter of life and death. It does not advocate violence against non-Jews in any general sense and has no relevance in modern times. Leading Jewish authorities have consistently repudiated this interpretation.
3. “A goy (Gentile) who pries into the Law (Talmud) is guilty of death.” (Sanhedrin 59a)
Truth: This is a distortion. The actual discussion concerns the sanctity of Torah study and the responsibility of Jews to protect their traditions. There is no punishment prescribed for non-Jews studying Jewish texts. In fact, Judaism often encourages ethical individuals of all backgrounds to study moral teachings.
4. “To communicate anything to a Goy about our religious relations would be equal to the killing of all Jews.”
Truth: This is an outright invention. The Talmud does not contain such a statement. Jewish teachings emphasize honesty and fairness in interactions with all people, regardless of religion.
5. “If a Jew be called upon to explain any part of the rabbinic books, he ought to give only a false explanation.”
Truth: Another fabricated statement. Jewish ethics strictly prohibit lying, as honesty is a core Jewish value. The Torah commands, “You shall not bear false witness” (Exodus 20:16).
6. “Sexual intercourse with a little girl is permitted if she is three years of age.” (Yebamoth 11b)
Truth: This is a malicious distortion of a legal discussion about contracts of betrothal in ancient times. It does not permit or condone such actions. Judaism unequivocally condemns any form of child abuse.
7. “Jews may swear falsely by using subterfuge wording.”
Truth: This is completely false. Jewish law strictly prohibits false oaths and emphasizes truthfulness as a divine commandment (Leviticus 19:12).
8. “Do not save Goyim in danger of death.”
Truth: This claim is contradicted by Jewish law. Saving a life, known as Pikuach Nefesh, is a fundamental Jewish principle that applies to all human beings, regardless of religion or ethnicity.
9. “Show no mercy to the Goyim.”
Truth: Another fabrication. Judaism teaches compassion and mercy. Proverbs 12:10, for instance, states, “The righteous care for the needs of their animals,” emphasizing universal compassion.
10. “If it can be proven that someone has given the money of Israelites to the Goyim, a way must be found to wipe him off the face of the earth.”
Truth: This statement has no basis in any Jewish text. It is designed to perpetuate the antisemitic stereotype of Jews being obsessed with money.
11. “A Jew may keep anything he finds which belongs to the Akum (Gentile).”
Truth: Jewish law obligates the return of lost property to its rightful owner, regardless of their religion. Ethics and fairness are central to Jewish teachings (Deuteronomy 22:1-3).
12. “A Jew should make a false oath when the Goyim asks if our books contain anything against them.”
Truth: Completely false. Jewish tradition values honesty and the sanctity of oaths.
13. “The Jews are human beings, but the nations of the world are not human beings.” (Baba Mezia 114)
Truth: This is a complete misquote. The Talmud often uses metaphorical language, but the universal humanity of all people is a cornerstone of Jewish ethics. Claims like this deliberately twist text to spread hatred.
The Origins of These Lies
These fabricated quotes are part of a long history of antisemitic propaganda. Many of them originate from medieval Christian polemics against Jews, such as the work of Johann Andreas Eisenmenger in the 18th century. His book “Entdecktes Judenthum” (Judaism Unmasked) falsely attributed heinous statements to Jewish texts, which have been recycled by antisemites ever since.
Why These Lies Persist
Antisemitic claims like these are designed to delegitimize and demonize Jews by falsely portraying Jewish teachings as hateful. They rely on decontextualized, mistranslated, or outright fabricated quotes to stir up fear and hatred.
Conclusion
Spreading these lies not only fuels hatred but also undermines efforts to build understanding and coexistence between communities. The truth about Jewish teachings is one of universal ethics, compassion, and respect for all humanity. By debunking these falsehoods, we can counter antisemitism with facts and promote a world grounded in mutual respect and understanding.
Listen to the Podcast
